The Journal
Growth

92% of Black Friday influencer advice is ‘wE jUsT nEeD mOrE cReAtOrs’

Danielle Theobald
Danielle Theobald
Social Media Strategist · 29 Oct 2026 · 2 min read
92% of Black Friday influencer advice is ‘wE jUsT nEeD mOrE cReAtOrs’

92% of Black Friday influencer advice is ‘wE jUsT nEeD mOrE cReAtOrs’

No babe

You need the ones you've GOT to actually SELL!!

I've scaled 300+ health and wellness brands as a fractional CMO, and every single Q4 someone proudly shows me a dashboard with 200 partners on it.

But ultimately that doesn’t equal ROI and brand success when only 12 of them posted last month 🤡

That's not an affiliate program!

Black Friday is 29 days away. Here's what actually gets partners selling, and you more money:

→ Lock your rate NOW. Panic raising your mid-November rate gets noticed by creators and can deter potentially amazing partners

→ Recruit the right partner type, not the biggest following. I'd take a trusted nutritionist with 4k followers over a lifestyle account with 400k for a wellness brand any day.

→ Brief them before peak season. Assets, dates, hooks. Nobody films good content the night before Black Friday, and there’s nothing you can do about it.

→ More commission won't wake up a stagnant partner. Activation will.

Last November, a supplement founder asked me whether to double her rate the week before Black Friday. I told her she’s too late, and she’s gotta accept the loss. If she'd had a benchmark and activation in October, she’d have about $400k more in Black Friday sales.

So I ran that same brand through UpPromote Commission Benchmark Tool to see what’s actually going on. It matched us to the Fitness + Nutrition niche and showed an exact affiliate ICP that would drive the highest ROI

(and it’s not AI or guessing - it’s data from stores that have earned 5-figures from affiliates)

A benchmark isn't necessarily a rule (your margin decides the ceiling ofc), but it's a far better starting line than a guess or just following a competitor’s strategy

If you're a Shopify store getting ready for Black Friday and Cyber Monday, check your commission benchmark here: https://upmote.link/i5mqhn

Be honest... how many of your affiliates posted last month? 👀

Designed & built byDesigned & built byDesigned & built byDesigned & built byDesigned & built byDesigned & built byDesigned & built byDesigned & built by